|
Original
Passage I:
Height
connotes status in many parts of the world. Executive offices are
usually on the top floors; the underlings work below. Even being
tall can help a person succeed. Studies have shown that employers
are more willing to hire men over 6 feet tall than shorter men with
the same credentials. Studies of real-world executives and graduates
have shown that taller men make more money. In one study, every
extra inch of height brought in an extra $1,300 a year. But being
too big can be a disadvantage. A tall, brawny football player
complained that people found him intimidating off the field and
assumed he "had the brains of a Twinkie." (p. 301)
---Locker,
K. O. (2003). Business and administrative communication (6th
ed.). St. Louis, MO: Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
Let’s
first identify the main points in the original passage.
Topic
sentence: “Height
connotes status in many parts of the world.”
Main
point: “Even
being tall can help a person succeed.”
Main
point: “Executive
offices are usually on the top”
Main
point: “being
too big can be a disadvantage”
For
this example, we’ll look at multiple summaries.
As you read the sample summaries below determine if the main
points were included and if the unimportant points were discarded.
Also check to see if both wording and sentence structure do not
follow those of the original.
Summary
A:
Throughout the world, being tall will lead to
professional success. In fact, research shows that employers are
more likely to hire taller men and to pay them more, as compared to
shorter men with the same qualifications (Locker, 2003).
[This
summary is too brief. Further, it changes the meaning slightly,
giving the impression that being tall guarantees success.]
Summary
B:
In
most countries, height suggests status. For instance, higher
executives normally use top floors of office buildings. Further,
research shows that men over six feet tall are more likely to be
hired than those shorter than them but with the same qualifications.
Taller men also receive greater incomes, possibly as much as $1,300
a year more than those only one inch shorter than them. However, as
a tall and muscular football player points out, a disadvantage to
being tall is that some individuals may perceive you as threatening
or even dumb (Locker, 2003).
[This
summary is too long. Instead of focusing on the main points, it
includes all of the details that are in the original passage.]
Summary
C:
Though height
may connote slowness to some people, in the business world, it is
almost universally associated with success. For example, taller men
are more likely to be hired and to have greater salaries. Further,
those in top positions within a company are more likely to work on
the top floors of office buildings (Locker, 2003).
[This
summary is the most effective. In addition to including all of the
main points, it leaves out the unimportant details.]
|