|
Original
passage:
Statements
that seem complimentary in one context may be inappropriate in
another. For example, women in business are usually uncomfortable if
male colleagues or superiors compliment them on their appearance:
the comments suggest that the women are being treated as visual
decoration rather than as contributing workers. (p. 323)
---Locker,
K. O. (2003). Business and administrative communication (6th
ed.). St. Louis, MO: Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
Let’s
first identify the important ideas in this passage:
·
Appropriateness of statements is situational.
·
Example is that working women may view compliments about
appearance as offensive.
·
These compliments can be offensive because they may imply
women are “decoration.”
Read
the sample paraphrases below. For each of the paraphrases, determine
if both wording and sentence structure were changed. Also check to
see if all of the original points were included and if the original
meaning was retained.
Paraphrase
A:
Words
or expressions which appear favorable in one situation might be
improper in a different situation. For instance, employed females
are often uneasy when they are given positive comments on their
looks. These remarks imply that the females are being viewed as
adornment instead of as productive employees (Locker, 2003).
[Although
this paraphrase does a good job of changing the wording, it is not
effective for two main reasons. First, it follows the sentence
structure of the original passage too closely. Second, it fails to
mention anything about "male colleagues or superiors."
It also follows the same order or structure of ideas.]
Paraphrase
B:
Some
statements may be inappropriate in one context, even though they
are complimentary in another. Compliments by male colleagues
or
superiors regarding a female coworker’s appearance, for example,
often make the woman feel uncomfortable. Instead of treating the
women as contributing workers, men obviously think of them as visual
decoration (Locker, 2003).
[While
this paraphrase does a better job of changing the sentence
structure, it also is uneffective. It uses too many of the words
from the original passage. Further, it changes the meaning when it
declares that "men obviously think of them as visual
decoration." It
also follows the same order or structure of ideas]
Paraphrase
C:
Women
may feel uneasy upon receiving ordinarily positive comments on their
appearance from male coworkers or supervisors. To these women, the
remarks carry an implied meaning: instead of being thought of as
productive employees, they are actually being viewed as just a
pretty part of the atmosphere. Depending on the situation, words or
expressions which appear favorable may actually be unsuitable in a
conversation (Locker, 2003).
[This
paraphrase is the most effective. In addition to changing both the
wording and sentence structure, it includes all points and retains
the meaning of the original passage.
It also changes the order of ideas.]
|